When Burnham first announced his Cabinet, many speculated it would entail a 3% increase in defence spending by 2030 (1) . However, with recent developments, it is now likely that Burnham is more focused on his domestic agenda, ruling out any increases in defence spending at the cost of social welfare (2), whilst his government remains steadfast in delivering cost-of-living improvements for the people to bring the welfare bill down instead. This meets the ‘Makerfield test’, in which PM Burnham seeks to create policy to benefit local places(3). Meanwhile, Burnham has pledged to meet the broader NATO target of reaching 3.5% defence spending by 2035 (4), and his foreign policy will seem to be defined by principles, as seen by the recent trade bans imposed on Israeli settlers, to protect the two-state solution (5).
John Healey’s decision to defer the 3% defence spending target until the multi-year spending review in 2027 (6) may come as a surprise, because of his relentless pursuit of increased defence spending. John Healey first got involved with the Treasury under the Blair and Brown governments as a junior minister, before being appointed as Defence Secretary under Starmer in 2024. As Defence Secretary, Healey strongly supported the armed forces, pledging that the UK would be the ‘leading European nation in NATO’ (7), whilst supporting the government’s ‘root and branch’ review into defence, hoping that it would lead to improvements . He responded to this review with harsh criticism, saying that ‘Britain’s defence position was worse than we thought’, calling for further funding (8). Healey eventually resigned from the government after its 2026 Defence investment plan, stating that the 13.5 billion that the Treasury allocated for defence was short of the 28 billion needed, reprimanding the Starmer government as he resigned as Defence Secretary (9). Being appointed Chancellor of the Exchequer, the second most powerful office in the country (10); being given power over the Treasury he once clashed with to increase defence spending. This may not be the reason Healey was appointed; instead, he was appointed by Burnham for being a Chancellor easy to mould and fitting with his overall domestic economic agenda, which takes priority, having worked on housing before. Healey may also have to reshape his defence vision in line with the limited constraints of the budget in relation to all the promises of the government.
Meanwhile, although Burnham seems to be focusing on improving domestic affairs, and taking a principled approach to foreign policy, this may come with some challenges. It is increasingly clear we live in an unstable and dangerous world, as war continues in Europe, with Russia waging a war of aggression on European soil, whilst threatening European Allies of Ukraine; through incursions into European territory, like Poland and Lithuania (11), and excursions off the coast of Britain (12). Argentina is even eyeing up the overseas territory of Britain in the Falklands. In this unstable world, inability to commit spending to defence can come under increasing political scrutiny, especially from those to the right of the political aisle. Healey is under increasing pressure to increase defence budgets to accelerate Britain to matching NATO spending targets, which could put the Treasury under increasing strain.
Certainly, Burnham and John Healey navigate complicated choices in defence spending, balancing Burnham’s much-needed cost-of-living and welfare fixes for everyday people. Therefore, John Healey has had to balance these considerations with his defence goals, scaling back his extortionate defence spending goals, whilst the current NATO spending targets should continue to be firmly upheld for national security. Hopefully John Healey, continues to represent the Labour way in his upcoming budget, continuing to fund welfare and cost-of-living improvements in spite of any changes to defense spending.
References:
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/sep/04/british-army-halt-non-essential-training-exercises-save-money
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5yw3223w1vo
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5yw3223w1vo
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/09/17/nato-chief-burnham-increase-defence-spending/
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/oct/14/uk-sanctions-powers-action-supporters-israeli-settlements
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2026/aug/28/john-healey-uk-defence-spending-target-budget
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/article/2024/jul/10/uk-will-be-leading-european-nation-in-nato-defence-secretary-says
https://www.rusi.org/news-and-comment/in-the-news/problems-british-military-much-worse-we-thought-defence-secretary-john-healey-
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c9w2lkd29l8o
https://www.gov.uk/government/ministers/chancellor-of-the-exchequer
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/nato-jets-shoot-down-drone-in-lithuania-as-russia-continues-to-provoke-europe
https://news.sky.com/story/russian-warship-carries-out-live-fire-weapons-exercise-46-miles-off-uk-coast-mod-says-13561289